Car review: Xpeng's G6 has 'slight edge' over Tesla's Model Y with 'fool's errand' lidar

In This Article:

The SCMP is embarking on a six-part series of motoring reviews to focus on Chinese electric vehicles that are made for the export market, either in the right-hand drive versions or their original left-hand drive editions. In the first of this six-part series, Mark Andrews puts Xpeng's G6 sports-utility vehicle through the paces, concluding that it is not so much a car that you drive than the car that drives you.

Xpeng is currently the biggest disappointment of the three best-known Chinese electric vehicle (EV) start-ups, selling fewer cars than Li Auto or Nio.

Where Xpeng does better is in the global market. The G6 sports-utility vehicle, launched in June 2023, is the vanguard of Xpeng's push into Hong Kong's right-hand drive market with its larger sibling the X9 people-mover.

Do you have questions about the biggest topics and trends from around the world? Get the answers with SCMP Knowledge, our new platform of curated content with explainers, FAQs, analyses and infographics brought to you by our award-winning team.

How does the G6 handle? The Guangzhou-based carmaker recently put the SUV to a test at the Guangdong International Circuit in Zhaoqing, going toe-to-toe against Tesla's bestselling Model Y and - rather surprisingly - BMW's iX3.

The G6 and Model Y both outperformed the iX3 on the track, which was unsurprising since both were designed-from-scratch EVs, each with dual-motors. The iX3 was converted from the petrol-guzzling X3, with only an electric motor on the rear axle.

Customers around Xpeng G6 sport-utility vehicle (SUV) at a showroom on June 14, 2023. Photo: Weibo alt=Customers around Xpeng G6 sport-utility vehicle (SUV) at a showroom on June 14, 2023. Photo: Weibo>

I felt that Xpeng had a slight edge over Tesla in the driving experience. But with neither car aiming to be the all-out performance model, their handling and drive on the track was moot. What is more important is how the G6 handles on the public road. In this matter, the G6 is not so much a car that you drive, than a car that drives you.

Xpeng, founded 10 years ago, is the self-anointed leader in China's assisted-driving technology. It fought a lawsuit in 2020 with Tesla over alleged theft of autonomous driving software codes, which was eventually dropped by the plaintiff. Xpeng was the world's first to launch a mass-produced car, the P5, equipped with Lidar, using lasers for range and guidance. Elon Musk famously quipped that installing lidar on production models was "a fool's errand," and Tesla's camera-based FSD guidance system is now under investigation by the US National Highway Traffic Safety Administration after several fatal crashes. The G6 comes with its XNGP fully loaded and fully functioning.