Millions of dollars in student loan debt could have been cancelled already had the student loan machinery worked properly, according to a government watchdog.
A new report by the Government Accountability Office (GAO) looked into income-driven repayment (IDR) plans and found that as of June 1, 2021, around 7,700 student loans were due to be forgiven under existing rules — but the Education Department (ED) had only approved 157 loans to actually be discharged.
"Until Education takes steps to address such errors, some borrowers may not receive the IDR forgiveness they are entitled," the report stated. "This risk will increase as Education data show loans potentially eligible for IDR forgiveness will climb to about 1.5 million loans by 2030."
IDR plans allow student loan borrowers to drop their monthly payments to as low as $0 if their income dips below a certain threshold. If they complete 10, 20, or 25 years of payments, depending on their plan, they qualify to have the rest of their debt written off by the federal government.
Screenshot of GAO report on IDR student loans.
“Today’s GAO report confirms serious problems with the management of Income-Driven Repayment plans, which were intended to serve as a safety net for low-income student borrowers and provide them with a clear path to loan forgiveness,” House Education and Labor Committee Chairman Bobby Scott (D-VA) said in a statement on Wednesday.
In a letter within the report, Federal Student Aid Chief Operating Officer Rich Cordray acknowledged several recommendations by the GAO and stated that he's “committed” to improving the experience for student borrowers by adopting new measures.
IDRs were an Obama-era initiative
The GAO report highlighted how the IDR initiative — implemented by the Obama administration to tackle rising student loan debt — has largely failed.
"We... were very focused on trying to improve income-driven repayment plans and our hope was in the Obama administration that income-driven repayment would help address the student debt crisis," John King, a former Education Secretary in the Obama administration, told Yahoo Finance recently. "But the reality is, it hasn't."
About $500 billion in outstanding federal Direct Loans are being repaid by borrowers through IDR, according to the GAO.
Why only 157 and not 7,700 student loans were cancelled
The GAO report highlighted how a lack of data hindered accurate payment counts and led to confusion over cancellation of debt.
Roughly 70,300 loans had been in repayment long enough to possibly qualify for forgiveness as of September 1, 2020. Of these loans, 62,600 did not qualify for forgiveness, including 2,700 that were in default.
Another 7,700 loans that were in repayment — around 11% of the loans analyzed — could be "potentially eligible" for IDR forgiveness, but the government's repayment data did not provide enough information on why these loans had not been forgiven back in September 2020. ED approved cancellation for 157 loans under IDR as of June 1, 2021.
"Education officials said data limitations make it difficult to track some qualifying payments and older loans are at higher risk for payment tracking errors," the GAO report stated.
A recent NPR investigation detailed systematic mismanagement of the payment count, including how paperwork often went missing when loans transferred from one servicer to another over the years.
The GAO stressed that the problem needed an urgent fix.
"Until Education takes steps to address such errors, some borrowers may not receive the IDR forgiveness they are entitled," the report stated, adding: "This risk will increase as Education data show loans potentially eligible for IDR forgiveness will climb to about 1.5 million loans by 2030."
By 2030, over 1.5 million student loans could potentially qualify for income-driven repayment forgiveness. (Chart: GAO)
Biden's latest effort to cancel debt
The Biden administration has recently taken steps to address the massive IDR debacle, bringing borrowers on 10- and 20-year forgiveness plans closer to the end goal in two ways.
ED continued its student loan cancellation effort by giving borrowers retroactive credit for "forbearance steering," a practice involving student loan servicers pushing borrowers into unnecessary interest-accruing forbearance.
ED also said it will also take greater care to accurately track monthly payments for borrowers on IDR.
Together, the news is expected to cancel the student debt of 40,000 borrowers who are under the Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) program while 3.6 million more will move closer towards forgiveness.
Lawmakers lauded ED's recent moves to address the broken IDR system, noting that they will likely help many who may be struggling with their student debt.
Rep. Scott stated that he was "pleased that the Biden-Harris Administration announced steps to fix the problem and help students receive the loan forgiveness to which they are entitled."
A graduate of The City College of New York stands in his seat at his commencement ceremony in Manhattan on May 31, 2019. REUTERS/Gabriela Bhaskar ·(Gabriela Bhaskar / Reuters)
Advocates, meanwhile, slammed ED for not doing more.
“The failure of the ED to take responsibility for it and its servicers failures is inexcusable," Persis Yu of the Student Borrower Protection Center said in a statement. "For eight years, borrowers have been robbed of time that should count towards debt cancellation and ED did nothing to help them."
Yu said that ED's move to reform IDR "is a good first step to remedy some of the problems identified in the GAO report, but it does not go far enough." She called for ED to also count time spent in default as on-time monthly payments made towards the 20- or 25-year forgiveness plan.
“The problems identified suggest a much deeper systemic problem within the student loan system," Yu added. "We cannot rely on individual programmatic fixes to fix systemic problems. Widespread debt cancellation is needed immediately."
