Deborah Pawlowski; IR; Evans Bancorp, Inc.
David Nasca; President & CEO; Evans Bancorp, Inc.
John Connerton; Treasurer; Evans Bancorp, Inc.
Alex Twerdahl; Analyst; Piper Sandler & Co.
Greetings and welcome to the Evans Bancorp's fourth quarter fiscal year 2023 financial results. At this time, all participants are in a listen only mode. (Operator Instructions) As a reminder, this conference is being recorded. It is now my pleasure to introduce you to your host, Deborah Pelowski, Investor Relations for Evans Bancorp. Thank you, Deborah, you may begin.
Thank you, Alicia, and good afternoon, everyone. We appreciate your taking the time to join us today as well as your interest in Evans Bancorp. Joining me here are David Naska, our President; and CEO and John Connerton, our Chief Financial Officer. David and John are going to review the results for the fourth quarter of 2023 and provide an update on the company's strategic progress and outlook. After that, we will open the call for questions. You should have a copy of the financial results that were released today after the markets closed and if not, you can access them on our website. At evansbank.com. As you may be aware, we may make some forward-looking statements during the formal discussion as well as during the Q&A. These statements apply to future events that are subject to risks and uncertainties as well as other factors that could cause actual results to differ materially from what is stated on today's call. These risks and uncertainties and other factors are provided in the earnings release as well as with other documents filed by the company with Securities and Exchange Commission. Please find those documents on our website [email protected] for that. Let me turn it over to David to begin.
Thank you, Debbie, and good afternoon everyone. We appreciate you joining us today. I will start with a review of the highlights from the past year, including the strategic initiatives we completed in the fourth quarter and we will then hand it off to John to discuss our results in detail. 2023 was a year that can be characterized as one of resilience. With a backdrop of interest rate volatility and economic challenges that accelerated throughout the year, the entire evidence team continued to deliver results. Net income was constrained by margin pressure due to the acceleration of funding costs, which rose faster than asset yields as banks responded to the steepest Federal Reserve. Increase in rates in decades and fought to maintain liquidity during the time of industry concern. We believe we managed this unique environment well by retaining key relationships, deposits and our liquidity position. In addition, growth, while difficult to come by was attained through our commercial business development and lending activity. The bank instituted Cecil at the beginning of 2023, which provided increased allowance for credit losses of $2.7 million. Our credit trends have remained favorable as we experienced continued improvement in criticized assets and low charge offs this past year.
Combined with improved economic conditions, we saw a muted provision impact in 2023. During the year, we continued proactive measures to control costs, deliver efficiencies and scalability, and improve the overall customer experience with new technology and process improvements. Of note, total non interest expense for the year decreased about $550,000 or 1%, which reflected our branch rationalization. Earlier in the year, as well as other. Which is which was which were partially offset by investments in technology and the community. The bank has maintained focus on return of capital to shareholders and total shareholder returns for the year. Dividends totaled $1.32 per share, which was up 5% and equated to a yield of about 4.3%.
Turning to the strategic actions taken during the fourth quarter for more than 20 years, insurance had been an integral part of Evans Bank. Ultimately, we built a successful business that was highly valued on November 30, 2023, the company finalized the sale of The Evans Agency to Arthur J. Gallagher & Company for $40 million. A question could be why did we sell? Growth and insurance required additional investments and acquisitions have become increasingly competitive based on how big insurance companies value assets and how they are financing them. We completed a significant amount of research and validated the opportunity that existed for sale along with exercising what we felt was a fiduciary responsibility to realize the value created. The decision was also driven in part by recognition that the Evans agency could realize greater opportunity for success and sustainability integrated with one of the top insurance and benefits companies in the world. AJ Gallagher is a growth focused insurance first company with broader scope and scale to provide optimal benefits for all stakeholders.
Of the objectives for the deal, a key one, was to ensure a good home for our associates and clients. There were no job eliminations and current leadership in the 60-plus direct employees of the agency were all offered positions with Gallagher. Clients will have access to a greater breadth of insurance expertise in specialty areas while experiencing the continuity of working with their current talented team of agency associates and leadership. In the end, we believe the combination provides the best opportunity to elevate our customers experience and provide our associates significant opportunities for career growth and the flourish with enhanced resources.
Gallagher will remain an insurance partner, with Evans providing commercial employee benefits and personal insurance products to our existing and prospective commercial municipal public entity and retail clients. From a shareholder perspective, we believe the rationale was compelling. This was unique opportunity to monetize the strategic investments. Meet in insurance services and allows us to optimize our capital and unlock value that we do not believe was being recognized in our stock. The sale price represented a substantial premium for the agency at almost 20 years of earnings. It eliminates about $12 million of goodwill and other intangible assets, resulting in approximately $4.55 per share tangible book value improvement.
The after tax gain was approximately $13 million, which provides us with the flexibility to strategically redeploy capital back into our core banking franchise. Given the current environment, we will continue to review a broad range of options to determine the best uses for this capital. Ultimately, we believe there are ample, ample opportunities to grow and create shareholder value. This includes the balance sheet restructuring that we compute in the fourth quarter, which consisted of selling 78 million of available for sale investment securities, predominantly US Treasuries and government sponsored agency securities.
Proceeds realized from the restructuring totaled $73 million, which were used to pay down short term borrowings and a $5,000,000 loss, was recognized on the sale. This transaction reduces a portion of the bank's liability sensitivity and is expected to improve returns in 2024 by enhancing our net interest margin. John will give you more details on that in a moment.
Looking forward, headwinds are expected to continue for community and regional banks with likely pressures on margins, growth and funding until interest rates recede. We are seeing signs of moderation in deposit cost increases and John will talk to our NIM expectations during his remarks. Although we do not have control over economic conditions, we are focused on what we can impact, which is growth in our core banking model and controlling cost to optimize our efficiency. With that, I'll turn you over to John to run through our results in greater detail, and then we will be happy to take any questions. John?
John Connerton
Thank you, David, and good afternoon everyone. For the quarter, we delivered earnings of $10.2 million or $1.85 per diluted share, which was up from last year's fourth quarter and the sequential third quarter largely due to the gain from the sale of The Evans Insurance Agency. Offsetting these increases was the loss from the sale of investment securities and a decrease in net interest income.
Net interest income was impacted over both comparable periods by higher interest expense given intense competitive pressure on deposit pricing, which began to accelerate at the start of the year. This more than offset increases in interest income driven by growth in our variable rate portfolios filing the Federal Reserve Series of rate increases.
As was as was discussed in our third quarter earnings call in October, the sequential third quarter net interest margin was impacted by 8-basis points from the reversal of approximately $400,000 of interest income, primarily resulting from one large commercial loan that was put on non accrual. Adjusting for this impact, NIM for the sequential third quarter was 2.87%. Therefore, on an adjusted basis, we saw a 12 basis point decrease in the quarter to 2.75%, which although at a reduced pace from recent quarters, continues to be driven by increased interest expense from higher deposit.
I will talk to, our net NIM expectations at the end of my remarks. The $282,000 in the provision for credit losses was predominantly due to the loan portfolio growth and higher reserves on individually analyzed loans, partially offset by peer group metrics and economic factors. Non interest income was up. From both the link quarter and the previous year's fourth quarter as a result of the gain on the sale of our insurance agency, which David discussed in length.
The gain was offset by a loss of $5 million from the sale of the $78 million in securities, which were yielding 2.12% and were used to reduce wholesale borrowings with a weighted average cost of 5.30%. The balance sheet restructure has an earned back of 2.2 years and is expected to have a $2.3 million positive impact on net interest income in 2024.
Non interest income was $3.4 million after removing one time transactions relating to the gain on sale of the insurance agency and the loss on the sale securities, which was down approximately 30% over last year's fourth quarter and down 62% sequentially. Insurance which typically is the largest contributor within this category. Net income of $1.6 million, which reflects after the sale of the insurgents agency on November 30th, only two months of revenue earned by the agency. This accounted for approximately $600,000 decrease from the prior year's fourth quarter. The reduction from the sequential third quarter was also impacted by the abbreviated months of operation and the third quarter had higher seasonal commissions earned from institutional clients.
Other income decreased $200,000 from the third quarter of 2023 due to movements in mortgage servicing rights. The decrease from last year's fourth quarter was primarily due to $200,000 gain on sale of assets that was acquired in foreclosure and sold in the fourth quarter of 2022 and included $200,000 of revenue recognized relating to rents received from the acquired asset prior to the sale.
Total non interest expense increased $1.9 million from the sequential third quarter and was up $1.4 million from last year's fourth quarter. The driver of these increases was largely within the salaries and employee benefits line due to greater incentive accruals. As a result of the execution of the strategic sale of Evans Insurance Agency, the company reached performance levels and recognized a corresponding incentive in the fourth quarter? The incentive increased from the sequential third quarter by $2.2 million and increased $1.6 million from prior from the prior year's fourth quarter. Offsetting both increases from prior periods was the partial quarter of salary activity due to former insurance employees.
2023 full year expenses attributed to the insurance agency was $6.8 million. Adjusting for the reduction of the expenses related to the insurance agency, the company expects expenses to decrease 1.5% in 2024 from 2023. Turning to the balance sheet and reviewing movements, in the fourth quarter, total loans were up approximately $17 million. Of that, commercial loans increased 2% or $13 million.
Net commercial originations were $58 million during the quarter compared with $62 million of net originations in the third quarter. We are being selective in our underwriting decisions, but are seeing opportunities in commercial real estate including multifamily and warehouse facilities that are meeting. Our credit parameters. The C & I funding rates remain muted and continue to impact growth in that portfolio. The current pipeline is strong and stands at $75 million at quarter end. We expect total commercial loan growth to be approximately 4% in 2024.
Credit metrics remain sound with non performing loans remaining flat for the quarter. Criticized loans decreased slightly by $5 million from $76 million at September 30th to $71 million as of the end of the fourth quarter. This is a $21 million decrease from last year's fourth quarter of $92 million.
Average total deposit balances decreased to $1.65 billion during the quarter when compared to $1.87 billion in the third quarter. Reflected in the deposit decrease was the seasonal outflow of municipal deposits and commercial deposits, which is typical this time of year. However, as has occurred in previous cycles, balances have and are expected to continue to migrate into different products. Specifically, we are seeing commercial clients migrate funds from the demand deposit accounts and the sweep accounts, and we expect consumer clients to continue moving funds from saving accounts to CDC.
At December 31st, the percentage of uninsured and uncollateralized deposits was at 15%. As with many banks, we will continue to fight for deposits by being proactive with pricing and maintaining competitive rates in our markets. Market deposit rates have stabilized during the fourth quarter due to expectations of decreases in Fed funds during 2024. The bank is managing its deposit pricing strategy to include balancing liquidity with profitability. Our actions in the market include. Offering shorter terms on CD products and reserving preferred pricing for core client.
We expect that continued competition for deposits will mute growth for the full year 2024 to a low single digit increase. These trends and pricing pressures continue to impact our margin for the fourth quarter, our expectation is deposit betas. Although de Accelerating will continue to increase cost of funds. However, with the impact of the balance sheet restructure we we expect our NIM to be flat in the first quarter of 2024. Beyond the first quarter, it's difficult to forecast given external macro forces such as timing of of potential future Fed break moves and how competition may play out. But our current expectation is that NIM pressure moderates further during the rest of the year. With that, operator, we would now like to open the line for questions.
Operator
(Operator Instructions) Nick Cucharale - Hovde Group
Nick Cucharale
Hey everyone. Good afternoon. I appreciate the commentary on the the near term NIM outlook for flatness in the first quarter and then moderating pressure afterwards. If we start to get fed cuts in the middle of the year or are you set to benefit substantially?
John Connerton
I mean, I won't really quantify it, Nick, but yes, you know breaks down from. The Fed we would we? Would begin to or we would be able to benefit, especially on our cost of funds, but I don't think it's it's not going to be a sea change, but it it should stem the tide and and moderate. Nim compression even further, and hopefully as our assets reprice, will start to to benefit and see some increase. In our new.
Nick Cucharale
OK. And then in light of the capital generated from the sale of the insurance operation and what sounds like another year of moderate loan growth are, are there other capital actions you're looking at, are there additional restructurings or are buybacks on the table?
David Nasca
Buybacks are on the table. We have looked at those we've talked before. It's difficult for us to get the bulk in that, but we're that is on the table and we continue to pursue all our avenues. That's one of them. We've made other investments in things like our Rochester growth. But certainly that's on the table.
Nick Cucharale
OK. And then on the the securities portfolio, are the sales this quarter or after the sales this quarter you're you're down to 13% of assets, are we at the point where you're beginning to add to the investment portfolio or is that that book still in run off mode?
John Connerton
Still in run off mode.
Nick Cucharale
And then as it as it relates to the tax rate, I saw the commentary regarding the non deductible goodwill in the quarter. What's your forecast for the effective tax rate going forward?
John Connerton
That should be around 22%.
Operator
Alex Twerdahl Piper Sandler & Co.
Alex Twerdahl
So it seems like the securities transaction you did basically offset the lost earnings from the insurance business basically completely. Is that kind of how you thought about doing sort of the size of what you did? Or maybe talk a? Little bit more about I guess exactly how you decide what to restructure on the securities portfolio.
John Connerton
Well, I think we when we when we looked at the size of the capital that we wanted to utilize, I think we looked at our capital levels and where we'd like to be. Probably Alex is was the biggest priority like we knew that we would be taking in this capital from the the insurance gain, but we wanted to utilize some of for the restructure. But I think what? Mostly drove. It was we like where our capital rate ratios are currently to do the things that David just discussed. As far as give us the flexibility to to do buybacks, to continue to invest in, in our business.
David Nasca
I think the one thing I'd say also Alex is. We looked at this thing when we sold the insurance agency, and I've been saying it all along, we. We fast forwarded like 20 years worth earnings. I know people want the current earnings that way, but we're looking at this as a chance to bringing capital and redeploy that. And we calibrated the, the loss that we wanted to take based on where we want our capital position as John just said. So I just reemphasize that.
Alex Twerdahl
Yeah. When you when you guys think about sort of where you want the capital position are you are you looking at TCe ratio, are you looking at that Tier 1 leverage ratio? I guess what like what's the, what's the metric that that you would point towards as being the limiting metric?
John Connerton
Our Tier 1. Leverage ratio is kind of what we're looking at.
Alex Twerdahl
Okay. And would be the goal to keep that sort of above 10%?
John Connerton
Well, close to 10% you know within that range.
Alex Twerdahl
Okay. And then as we think about loan growth coming on today, maybe talk a little bit about the types of opportunities you're seeing in terms of the yields relative to the book yield and you know is, I guess the lower the the 4% growth which you know a little bit lower than maybe you've got in years past. Is that driven? More about by the appetite of your balance sheet or or more about the opportunities you're seeing in the market.
John Connerton
I think we're. Still seeing a little, as I mentioned, we're seeing a little challenge on our C and I side from our customers drawing on their lines. And you know that that draw percentage is down significantly and we we haven't seen that move. So that does temper some of our growth. The areas that we see in the growth we. We do have a good we do have a good. We do have a good pipeline, a lot of that pipeline is C and I, but I think we're seeing it in both both C and I and commercial real estate and it's kind of across our across our regular typical stuff that we do within our portfolio back to the rates. I mean the rates that we're getting on the on the. Lines are is north of 8% and term is north of 6.5%, 7%.
David Nasca
But, but let me say additively, we are being considerate of our credit quality at this moment. We're making sure that we're living to our credit quality and getting the returns we want out of these deals one and two is your question directly is we're seeing. A little less activity in the marketplace right now, but we're pretty open for business right now if if the market heats up, you know that number could move a little bit, but we we do have a good pipeline as John said, but we're making sure that we're doing deals. That fit our credit to quality.
Alex Twerdahl
Okay. And and as you're thinking about, I guess back to the capital question and sort of the uses. Of capital are there, would you consider M&A as one of those uses of capital? I know there's not a lot in the way of sort of the. Plain vanilla you. Know bank out there. Maybe. But you know, if you kind of look a little bit more and think about branches or other things like that, is that something you'd consider?
David Nasca
Yes, I think we consider uh we're considering all opportunities. So short answer is yes. As you said, there's not a lot of opportunities to do a lot right this second, but we consider those things. But we also think that there's growth on our horizon and that capital helps us get there to the our native growth too.
Operator
Christopher O’Connell, Keefe, Bruyette & Woods
Christopher O’Connell
Just wanted to start off on the expenses, you know, appreciate the guide and you know hoping to just get a little bit of color as to you know the starting point, you know particularly in the comp line given the insurance fall off and the incentive accruals in the fourth quarter. Where do you think you know that line item kind of starts off the year?
John Connerton
Yeah. So probably in the first quarter, our expectations of our salary line item would be around $7.3 million that if you, if you take, if you normalize ourany of the quarters of insurance was about $1.5 million dollars on that salary line.
Christopher O’Connell
And the does the 2024 guide does. Does the OpEx guide assume you know, like that ascent of accruals are being hit at you know 100%?
John Connerton
They'll be reduced from this year just based on our expectation of where our performance is going to be.
Christopher O’Connell
Great. And then can you talk about, you know the deposit base and how much of the outflows this quarter were muni related and how much of those you think you know come back in in the first quarter and and if you think they'll be coming back into the same?
John Connerton
Sure. So in the fourth quarter, you know we can have variability on a day day-to-day basis. So spot balances are sometimes a little a little misleading. So if you that's why I talked to the average balance and really the average balance it's down you know close to $20 million and almost all of that is the Muni portfolio. And as far as we do expect you know we have a we expect to get that back and more the first quarter is when our municipals get their tax collections and and they come in and sit there through the first quarter quite a bit and then trail off and get utilized through the rest of the year until this until the schools get it. Back in the fall, so our expectation is we will get that back as well as and more.
Christopher O’Connell
Do you think? I mean, look, it looks like you know much of that came out of the non interest expense or non interest bearing deposit line. Do you think it comes back within that line or into different interest bearing products?
John Connerton
Yeah. I think within those within those line items, the the aggregate story is municipal, the the line item stories is our, our commercial accounts are continuing to move to some of our not our our interest bearing transactional accounts like our. Accounts it is at a low point, but we don't expect it to fully come back on the demand deposit line. A lot of those customers have have rotated into interest earning transactional lines like.
Christopher O’Connell
Great. And just, you know, thinking about. You know the NIM on a go forward basis, you know appreciate the flat guide you know for the first quarter. I mean how how do you guys think you know even you know I guess just assuming no. Fed cuts or any movement on that side, just stable rates, you know how far into 2024 do you think you know the NIM can bottom?
John Connerton
I guess. What I would say is, you know, as as our assets reprice right through principal pay downs or renewals, we expect a good chunk of the continued beta to be offset by that. So if we look forward, our expectation, our hope is that even after fourth quarter. Our balance sheet. Reprices itself, but we do think there is a potential again based on where the market goes, that betas can pick up here there without any Fed movement and that there could be if there could be some some, some continued pressure and most likely that pressure will be in the second quarter. But then as we move out and the Fed. Makes their movements. We would expect that third and fourth quarter see at minimum stabilization and maybe some expansion.
The the vagary if you will, Chris, is the competitive environment and we see a little bit of moderation there.
Christopher O’Connell
And do you guys have how much of of the assets are set to reprice in 2024?
John Connerton
So I've shared that I mean between between our investment principle run off our own, our loan run off, our renewals, it's around $300 million.
Christopher O’Connell
That's all I had. Thanks for taking my questions.
David Nasca
Thanks Chris.
Operator
Thank you. There are no further questions at this time. I'd like to turn the floor back over to Mr. Naska for closing comments.
David Nasca
Thank you, Alicia. I'd like to thank everybody for participating in the teleconference today. We certainly appreciate your continued interest and support and your quest. Please feel free to reach out at us anytime and we look forward to talking with all of you again when we report the first quarter 2024 results. So we hope you have a great day and thank you again for your interest.
Operator
Thank you. This concludes today's teleconference. You may disconnect your lines at this time. Thank you for your participation.